Current:Home > InvestFox News allowed to pursue claims that voting firm’s defamation suit is anti-free speech-LoTradeCoin
Fox News allowed to pursue claims that voting firm’s defamation suit is anti-free speech
View Date:2024-12-24 07:06:30
NEW YORK (AP) — A judge refused this week to toss out Fox News’ claims that voting technology company Smartmatic is suing the network to suppress free speech. The ruling means that both Smartmatic’s multibillion-dollar defamation lawsuit and the network’s counterclaims can continue toward an eventual trial.
Smartmatic says Fox News spread ruinous lies that the voting company helped rig the 2020 election against then-U.S. President Donald Trump. The network denies the allegations and is countersuing under a New York law against launching baseless litigation to squelch reporting or criticism on public issues — known as “strategic lawsuits against public participation,” or SLAPP, in legal parlance.
Smartmatic’s nearly 3-year-old suit is separate from, but similar to, the Dominion Voting Systems case that Fox settled for $787 million last year. Fox didn’t apologize but acknowledged that the court in that case had found “certain claims about Dominion to be false.”
Both sides in the Smartmatic case have tried unsuccessfully to get the other’s claims tossed out. Trial and appellate courts already gave Smartmatic the green light to continue. On Wednesday, trial Judge David B. Cohen said Fox News’ counterclaims also could go ahead.
Fox’s argument — essentially, that Smartmatic’s $2.7 billion claim is so inflated that it could only be meant to silence the network — “has not yet been adjudicated in any court,” Cohen wrote in his decision, filed Tuesday.
The Associated Press sent email messages seeking comment to the network and to Smartmatic’s attorneys.
Florida-based Smartmatic says that in the 2020 presidential election, its technology and software were used only in California’s Los Angeles County. The Democratic bastion — not seen as an election battleground — went for the Democratic nominee, current President Joe Biden.
But in Fox News appearances after Election Day 2020, Trump lawyers Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell portrayed Smartmatic as part of a broad scheme to steal the vote from the Republican incumbent. Giuliani asserted that the company had been “formed in order to fix elections.” Powell called it a “huge criminal conspiracy,” and the two claimed that proof would be forthcoming.
Federal and state election officials, exhaustive reviews in battleground states and Trump’s own attorney general found no widespread fraud that could have changed the outcome of the 2020 election. Nor did they uncover any credible evidence that the vote was tainted. Trump’s allegations of fraud also were roundly rejected by dozens of courts, including by judges whom he had appointed.
A Delaware judge presiding over the Dominion lawsuit ruled last March that it was “CRYSTAL clear” that none of the allegations that Trump allies made on Fox News about that company were true. The case was going to trial when Fox settled.
The Dominion case involved some of the same broadcasts and statements as the Smartmatic suit, and Smartmatic argued that the Delaware ruling should blow Fox’s counterclaims out of the water. Cohen said otherwise, citing — among other things — particulars of legal doctrine about when decisions in one case apply to another.
“Not all elements of plaintiff’s defamation claims have been already been determined” against Fox, he wrote.
Smartmatic blames Fox for ruining its reputation and business. Its value declined to “a fraction of what it was,” and support lines, customer-service inboxes and company officers were deluged with threats after the broadcasts, the voting company has said in court papers.
Fox News has said it was simply covering influential figures — the president and his lawyers — making undeniably newsworthy allegations of election fraud. The network also maintains that Smartmatic is greatly overstating its losses and Fox’s responsibility for them.
In its counterclaims, Fox is seeking attorneys’ fees and costs.
veryGood! (65)
Related
- Keke Palmer Says Ryan Murphy “Ripped” Into Her Over Scream Queens Schedule
- Georgia football coach Kirby Smart's new 10-year, $130 million deal: More contract details
- Counterfeit iPhone scam lands pair in prison for ripping off $2.5 million from Apple
- After the deluge, the lies: Misinformation and hoaxes about Helene cloud the recovery
- Voters in Oakland oust Mayor Sheng Thao just 2 years into her term
- A Tennessee nurse and his dog died trying to save a man from floods driven by Hurricane Helene
- Washington fans storms the field after getting revenge against No. 10 Michigan
- Don’t fall for fake dentists offering veneers and other dental work on social media
- See Leonardo DiCaprio's Transformation From '90s Heartthrob to Esteemed Oscar Winner
- Man charged with helping Idaho inmate escape during a hospital ambush sentenced to life in prison
Ranking
- High-scoring night in NBA: Giannis Antetokounmpo explodes for 59, Victor Wembanyama for 50
- How Trump credits an immigration chart for saving his life and what the graphic is missing
- Las Vegas Aces need 'edge' to repeat as WNBA champs. Kelsey Plum is happy to provide it.
- North Carolina native Eric Church releases Hurricane Helene benefit song 'Darkest Hour'
- Unexpected pairing: New documentary tells a heartwarming story between Vietnam enemies
- Washington state fines paper mill $650,000 after an employee is killed
- '19 Kids and Counting' star Jason Duggar and girlfriend Maddie tie the knot
- Bighorn sheep habitat to remain untouched as Vail agrees to new spot for workforce housing
Recommendation
-
Ashton Jeanty stats: How many rushing yards did Boise State Heisman hopeful have vs Nevada
-
What's the 'Scariest House in America'? HGTV aims to find out
-
Davante Adams pushes trade drama into overdrive with cryptic clues
-
You like that?!? Falcons win chaotic OT TNF game. Plus, your NFL Week 5 preview 🏈
-
Steelers shoot for the moon ball, but will offense hold up or wilt in brutal final stretch?
-
NFLPA calls to move media interviews outside the locker room, calls practice 'outdated'
-
FEMA has faced criticism and praise during Helene. Here’s what it does — and doesn’t do
-
Caitlin Clark Shares Tribute to Boyfriend Connor McCaffery After Being Named WNBA’s Rookie of the Year